Skip to content

RESEARCH COMPANION / CLAIMS

The making of a legend

How do a few names in a record become an accepted story? Begin by separating the statement from the embellishment.

A WORKED EXAMPLE

What Tanner records—and what he does not

The surviving return recordsLater accounts have assertedStatus
William Salisbury and John Salisbury both appear under 24 Jun 1675.They were father and son.Relationship not stated in the return.
The entries name those buried.The men acted together in a particular confrontation.Circumstances not stated in the return.
The clerk supplied an administrative burial date.The record proves a precise scene of death.A burial date is not an eyewitness narrative.

A later claim might still be testable using other evidence. The point is not to declare everything absent from a record false. It is to identify where each assertion actually originates.

UNDER CONSTRUCTION

Follow the claim from source to source

This section will expand into dated claim histories, with quotations and citations checked against the works in which they first appeared. Derivative accounts will not be counted as independent eyewitnesses.