Skip to content

Nicholas Tanner

NOTABLE PEOPLE

Nicholas Tanner

A clerk whose name matters because of his records

Nicholas Tanner appears in early Plymouth Colony and Swansea civic records, and his name is closely associated with the annual return of Swansea births, marriages and burials compiled in March 1675/76. The return includes nine men entered as buried on June 24, 1675, among them William Salisbury and John Salisbury. Tanner did not write a battle narrative. The town clerk’s responsibility was to supply vital events pursuant to a court order. Whether the surviving copied manuscript leaf was written by Tanner himself has not been established through comparison of his handwriting. [1–3]

A biography built from his recorded actions is more useful than speculating about how he escaped, where he hid or what he remembered in the chaos of King Philip’s War. His precise place of residence during the fighting, storage of Book A, and sources used to compile the return remain unknown. [1, 2]

Before the annual return: civic and colony records

Contemporary Plymouth Colony records contain other appearances of the name Nicholas Tanner, including entries relating to a 1669 grand inquest, a 1670 list of freemen, and 1671 town appointments. A 1670 list also names John Myles Jr. These records establish that the name appeared in civic contexts before Tanner’s 1675/76 return; without individual source and identity checks, they do not prove uninterrupted service in a particular office or that every appearance names the same individual. [4, 5]

Alverdo H. Mason’s 1900 introduction to Swansea Book A states that the first surviving town-clerk election is John Myles Jr. on May 19, 1670; that Nicholas Tanner was elected on June 26, 1674; and that John Brown was elected on October 25, 1677. These are the editor’s report of entries in the town book. The dates give Tanner a credible place in the sequence of clerks, but do not establish that he personally made each surviving entry or held physical possession of every leaf during the war. [3]

A 1674 Swansea vital return identifies James as a son of John Myles the younger and is associated with Tanner’s clerical returns. It distinguishes the younger Myles by name; it does not establish his relationship to every other record naming John Myles. The return’s precise attestation has not been independently collated for this profile. [4]

October 27, 1675: A dispute about access to records

A printed Plymouth Colony judicial record, reporting the court held on October 27, 1675, preserves a complaint brought by Joseph Kent of Swansea against Nicholas Tanner of the same town. Kent alleged that Tanner was withholding a copy of the town records relating to Kent’s acceptance or admission, even though authorities had required a copy. The passage records a complainant’s assertion, not a verified court finding that Tanner intentionally obstructed the record. The captured page does not supply a confirmed judgment on that complaint. [6]

This source has particular value because it places a records-access dispute during the months between the first Swansea attacks and Tanner’s March return. It does not establish where Tanner slept, whether Book A was then in his possession, whether the court secured the requested copy, or whether this dispute affected the later burial data. A dispute about one man’s town-admission papers cannot be promoted into proof of deliberate alteration of the casualty record. [6]

March 4, 1675/76: The annual return

The annual Swansea report is headed March 4, 1675 in the calendar used at the time, conventionally rendered March 4, 1675/76. It was submitted more than eight months after the June 1675 entries. The report lists vital events from the preceding year in response to the colony’s order and carries Tanner’s town-clerk attestation. The handwritten record is reproduced in a FamilySearch image of folio 64, image 200 of 369 in group 007009308. This handwritten copy is a different source object from Shurtleff’s 1857 typeset edition and Swansea’s damaged local Book A. [1–3]

The nine people entered as buried under June 24 are Gershom Cobb, Joseph Lewis, John Salisbury, John Jones, John Fall, Nehemiah Allin, Robert Jones, William Cohun/Cahoon and William Salisbury, with variant forms retained in the manuscript/transcription concordance. The sequence is NOT a military muster or a single contemporary eyewitness death report. The entry contains neither a list of kinships nor a death-site assignment for William or John Salisbury. [1, 2]

The document says “buried”; it is not evidence that every reported fatality occurred in the same incident or that the physical burials happened together at one place. Tanner’s sources for the return have not survived as a separate identifiable file. He might have used earlier records, supplied later corrections or learned some events from others, but none of those methods may be asserted as what he actually did without evidence. [1–3]

Swansea Book A: The other witness, damaged and incomplete

Mason’s 1900 printed transcription of Swansea Book A preserves four entries dated 24 June 1675 on manuscript p. 147: Joseph Lewis, John Salsbery, John Jones and John Full. A damaged fragment from p. 157, pasted to p. 158, separately preserves “Gersom Cobb buried the 24 day of Jun 167” with the last year digit missing. The printed page image supports the day and month, not a complete independent date for Cobb. The other four men in the colony return—Nehemiah Allin, Robert Jones, William Cahoon and William Salisbury—have no matching entry identified in the surviving Book A material reviewed. [2, 3]

Because the physical town book has missing and damaged leaves, an absence from its surviving printed transcription is not proof that an entry never existed or that Tanner fabricated it. Neither can the difference automatically be explained by town residency: Cobb was “of Middleborough” in a June 2, 1675 deed but appears in the Book A fragment. Book A and Tanner’s colony return are separate witnesses with separate physical histories. [2, 3]

A clerk’s report is an administrative reconstruction. The proper historical question is which evidence supports each entry, not whether a supposedly perfect clerk personally witnessed everything that it records. [1–3]

After the war: continued appearances

A 1681 Plymouth Colony court page includes Nicholas Tanner among men “propounded to be admitted” as freemen. That establishes a proposal, not his actual admission or the later disposition. Names on the same page cannot be assigned shared town affiliations from their proximity alone. [7]

A 1686 Massachusetts General Court Swansea list provides a further occurrence of Tanner’s name, but its precise function has not been established for this biography. His death occurred before 6 October 1708; that is a terminus, not an exact death date. A recorded Bristol County probate will naming Nicholas Tanner appears on register p. 205 (FamilySearch group 007703530, image 237/745), while a later executor’s accounting involving John Thomas appears on p. 249 (image 263/745). The two manuscript page images were visually reviewed for their record types; neither has been subjected here to a complete diplomatic transcription. The intervening image 238 belongs to adjacent probate material, not a second independent Tanner will. A grave location, complete household and parents remain unverified. [8, 10]

The limits of the June 1675 record

Cudworth’s near-contemporary reports, Mather and Hubbard’s printed compilations, Thomas’s letter as printed in 1854, and Tanner’s administrative return have different purposes, dates and opportunities for error. Similar counts do not permit us to allocate Tanner’s nine names among deaths at a guard, on the road and at Mattapoisett. [1, 2, 9]

Later accounts describing the recovery of human remains do not identify which, if any, of Tanner’s nine men those remains belonged to, or document a second burial for any named person. [2]

Tanner remains important because the record he attested preserves nine names whose deaths might otherwise be much harder to investigate. Its limits are not a personal failing that the surviving evidence permits us to assign to him.

Sources and controlled research

[1] Nicholas Tanner, Swansea annual vital-record return, 4 Mar 1675/76, handwritten manuscript fol. 64, Plymouth Colony records, FamilySearch image group 007009308 image 200/369. Compare Nathaniel B. Shurtleff, ed., Records of the Colony of New Plymouth, vol. 8 (Boston, 1857), 60–61; Shurtleff is a printed derivative, not another firsthand account.

[2] Tanner’s 4 Mar 1675/76 annual return (manuscript fol. 64) compared with Alverdo H. Mason’s edition of Swansea Book A (1900), pp. 147 and 157–158. The different physical records do not supply independent testimony of death circumstances.

[3] Alverdo H. Mason, ed., Book A of the Town of Swansea, 1662–1705 (East Braintree, 1900), introduction and transcriptions of manuscript pp. 147, 157–158. Original damaged leaves and literal names remain to be collated before reproduction.

[4] Plymouth Colony Court Orders and Swansea town/vital-record returns, 1669–1686; the specific surviving references include the 1670 freemen listing and the 1674 return naming James, son of John Myles the younger. The individual manuscript entries have not all been collated; no continuous term of office or full household is claimed.

[5] Plymouth Colony Court Orders, 1669 grand-inquest entry and 1671 Swansea town-appointments entry, associated with Nicholas Tanner (FamilySearch project-reference images 803 and 824, respectively; exact bound volume and original folio remain to be established). These support cautious name occurrences, not an uninterrupted personal biography.

[6] Plymouth Colony, Judicial Acts, October 27, 1675, printed p. 196, Joseph Kent v. Nicholas Tanner of Swansea; project reference PDF “1675 — Plymouth Colony court — Joseph Kent v. Nicholas Tanner — Swansea acceptance records — FS image 429.pdf,” FamilySearch image 429/939, group 007724437. The printed witness documents the COMPLAINT but not a verified resolution.

[7] Plymouth Colony Court Orders, June 7, 1681, list of freemen “propounded to be admitted” that names Nicholas Tanner; project research file “1681 — Plymouth Colony freemen propounded — Nicholas Tanner — FS image 814.pdf,” FamilySearch group 007724436, image 814 of 960. Preserve proposed-versus-admitted distinction.

[8] Massachusetts General Court Swansea list, 1686, manuscript image indexed under Nicholas Tanner (project locator, FamilySearch image 366); exact purpose and wording uncollated. This source is not used to assign a particular office.

[9] Compare James Cudworth to Josiah Winslow, 27 Jun 1675 (Boston Athenæum, Josiah Winslow Papers, Mss. .L461); Nathaniel Thomas’s 25 Jun letter as printed in Memorials of Marshfield (1854), 55; Increase Mather (1676), William Hubbard (1677), and Tanner’s separate colony return. These reports do not identify identical casualties.

.

[10] Bristol County, Massachusetts, recorded probate volume, will of Nicholas Tanner, manuscript p. 205, FamilySearch image group 007703530, image 237/745; executor account mentioning Nicholas Tanner and John Thomas, manuscript p. 249, same image group, image 263/745. Both recorded manuscript page images examined 3 November 2026 for record identity and broad chronology; not complete literal transcriptions. The records establish probate administration by 1708, not an exact death day.

Digitized published source: Plymouth Colony Records, vol. 8 (1857), pp. 60–61 — digital published edition.