MYSTERIES
The Servant Without a Name
A Suffolk Probate Puzzle
THE QUESTION
Can a Suffolk County probate inventory help identify the unnamed Black man enslaved by the Rev. John Myles, whose injuries were reported in June 1675? The 1675 Suffolk record names a deceased man called Menenie, but the connection has not been established. It raises a second, independent question: who was Dorcas, the woman appearing in the proceedings after his inventory, and what relationship—if any—did she have to Menenie?
THE NAME THAT THE LETTER DOES NOT GIVE
On 27 June 1675, James Cudworth wrote Plymouth governor Josiah Winslow about violence near the house or guard associated with the Swansea Baptist minister John Myles (also spelled Miles). He distinguished Gershom Cobb, whom he reported killed, from wounded men whose outcomes were still uncertain. For the man enslaved by Myles, Cudworth wrote that there was “no hope of life.” Cudworth did not name him.
William Hubbard’s later printed history says that a Black man enslaved by Myles died after being wounded. That is a later report of death, not a recovered personal name or an eyewitness date of death. The two texts should not be collapsed into a single fully documented biography.
The 27 June 1675 Cudworth letter records a badly wounded man but does not give his name. That absence led me to ask whether a separate surviving record might preserve a clue. The probate entry discussed here is a source I found myself; it was not identified for me by another researcher.
AN UNEXPECTED PAGE
While examining the Suffolk County probate register, I discovered an inventory for someone recorded as “Menenie Negro.” It appears on manuscript pages 266–267, in the opening reproduced as FamilySearch image 149 of image group 007703071. This independent discovery provided a possible name to investigate, but nothing in the register identifies Menenie as the unnamed man in Cudworth’s letter.
The inventory lists clothing, a bed and bedding, cookware, pewter, glassware and other household goods, with a recorded total of £9 14s 6d. A date appearing with the inventory is 4 July 1675; the appraisers signed on 19:6:75 (19 August 1675 under the contemporary numbered-month convention). In the subsequent probate proceedings a woman named Dorcas appears on 25 September 1675. The working source examination tentatively reads her surname as “Manning”; neither that reading nor the precise language of the administration entry has yet been confirmed by full manuscript collation. Her participation deserves attention in its own right.
These probate dates come shortly after the June attacks, which makes Menenie worth investigating. They do not identify a death date, locate him at Swansea, or establish any personal relationship between him and Dorcas.
WHO WAS DORCAS?
A name in a probate proceeding is a genuine clue, but not a certificate of marriage or kinship. Was Dorcas Menenie’s wife? His mother or sister? Another relative, a member of his household, an associate, a creditor, or a person acting in a legally defined capacity? The surviving working reading has not supplied an answer. We do not know that they were a couple, that Dorcas was Black, or that she was enslaved or free. None of these characteristics may be inferred simply because she appears in a proceeding about his estate.
The next evidentiary step is to read the exact clause in which Dorcas appears and identify what she did: did she take an oath, request or receive administration, provide an accounting, or appear in another capacity? Does the record use words such as wife, widow, daughter, mother, sister, servant, creditor, or administratrix—or does it give no relationship at all? Her provisional surname reading, “Manning,” must be tested against the handwriting and adjacent entries, not normalized into a family connection. Only then would a targeted search for her name and variants in contemporary Suffolk and Plymouth records be meaningful.
Even if no relationship can be established, Dorcas is part of Menenie’s documentary history. Her presence is one of the most potentially informative clues in a record that otherwise tells us little about his household or connections.
THE WRONG COURT?
This is the obstacle I cannot ignore. Swansea belonged to Plymouth Colony; Menenie’s estate appears in a Suffolk County, Massachusetts Bay probate register. If Menenie was the man wounded near Myles’s home, why would his estate be recorded in Suffolk rather than Plymouth?
There is a possible lead. John Myles took refuge in Boston during the war, according to later biographical scholarship. Boston lay in Suffolk County. But the timing and any effect of Myles’s move on the probate proceeding have not been established. The Suffolk entry does not name Myles as Menenie’s owner, employer, household head, executor or administrator. His later presence in Boston cannot, by itself, explain why Menenie’s estate appears here.
To test the idea, I would need records showing Menenie’s residence or legal circumstances, the basis for the Suffolk court’s jurisdiction, and an actual documentary connection to Myles or the Swansea guard. I would also need to search Plymouth Colony probate and court records for the unnamed casualty and for plausible variant names. Those checks have not yet been completed.
WHAT THE RECORD PROVES — AND DOES NOT
The record documents a deceased Black person called Menenie whose estate was inventoried in Suffolk County in 1675. It provides an unusually specific list of possessions and places Dorcas in the later proceedings. It does not say that Menenie was enslaved. It does not identify him as Myles’s unnamed servant, establish that he lived in Swansea, or provide a cause or place of death. Chronological proximity is a reason to investigate, not an identification.
There is another inventory on the same manuscript opening: that of John Fans, a merchant associated with Whithorn in Scotland. It is worth reading for its own sake, but it offers no evidence of a link to Menenie or Myles. John Fans’s separate probate inventory is discussed in his Notable People biography.
WHERE THE PUZZLE STANDS
Open. We have two unresolved questions, not one: whether the Suffolk estate of Menenie could belong to the unnamed man wounded near John Myles’s home, and who Dorcas was in the probate proceedings. The record names her but does not establish her relationship to him. A precise reading of the court language may produce a lead or demonstrate that the available evidence stops there. If neither question can be resolved, the inventory and Dorcas’s appearance still deserve to be documented for other researchers.
Menenie’s separate Notable People biography describes his recorded estate. This investigation considers the unproved possibility that he was the casualty mentioned near John Myles’s home.
Sources
1. James Cudworth to Governor Josiah Winslow, 27 June 1675, Josiah Winslow Papers, Boston Athenæum, Mss. .L461. The original manuscript is held by the Boston Athenæum.
2. William Hubbard, A Narrative of the Troubles with the Indians in New-England (Boston, 1677), later report of the injured man’s death; the specific passage has not been assigned a page citation here.
3. Suffolk County Probate Court, copied probate register, manuscript pp. 266–267, Menenie inventory and related entry, FamilySearch, “Suffolk, Massachusetts, United States records,” image group 007703071, image 149 of 922: View source. Provider sign-in or access restrictions may apply. Read the manuscript, not only search metadata.
4. The Suffolk probate image link above identifies the original record used here; additional unrelated inventories in the register are not evidence of Menenie’s identity.
5. The neighbouring Suffolk inventory for John Fans belongs to a separate estate and is discussed in his own biography. It does not show any connection with Menenie.
6. Thomas Richards, “Miles, John (1621–1683), Particular Baptist Leader and American Settler,” Dictionary of Welsh Biography (1959; updated 2024), reports his flight to Boston in 1675: View source. This is biographical scholarship, not direct evidence for Menenie’s probate jurisdiction.
