Skip to content

Increase Mather

NOTABLE PEOPLE

Increase Mather

A minister determined to correct the story

In 1676 the Boston minister Increase Mather published A Brief History of the Warr with the Indians in New-England. In his address to readers, he explained that he had kept notes from reports about the war and hoped to correct accounts he found unsatisfactory. The book was written close to the events but Mather did not claim to have been an eyewitness to the Swansea killings. [1]

In that address, Mather singled out an account attributed to a Boston merchant and another said to have been written by a Rhode Island Quaker. The merchant’s anonymous London pamphlet, The Present State of New-England, with Respect to the Indian War (1675), has sometimes been attributed to Nathaniel Saltonstall, but the identification is disputed. John Easton is a plausible identification for the Quaker; Mather did not name him. Neither attribution establishes eyewitness testimony. A similarly titled London publication in 1677 was another edition of William Hubbard’s history, not a reissue of the anonymous merchant pamphlet. [1, 12]

What he printed about Swansea

Mather arranged the reported deaths of 24 Jun 1675 into three parts: one English person killed after an assembly for fasting and prayer, two men killed while going for a surgeon, and six killed elsewhere. He then added the figures and reported nine deaths. Neither his casualty narrative nor the matching arithmetic names the victims. [1, 2] Cudworth’s separate 27 Jun 1675 letter reports two deaths on the road in connection with a mission to summon a surgeon. Similarities in reported numbers and purposes do not establish Mather’s information route or identify the victims.

Nicholas Tanner’s Swansea annual return separately names nine men as buried under 24 Jun. The temptation is to treat Tanner’s names as a key to Mather’s three incidents. That inference is not demonstrated. The return speaks to burials, Mather to a compiled narrative of deaths. Agreement in the number nine does not establish identical people, place or precise timing. [2]

A disagreement inside one book

Mather reproduced Plymouth Colony material in the separately paginated postscript to his own work. In the 1676 printing this reports “Layton” slain at Fall River on 24 June and “divers” killed at Swansea on 25 June, whereas the main narrative counts nine Swansea deaths on 24 June. The later 1859 edited colony records expand the name to “Thomas layton,” but that edition is not another 1676 eyewitness. These distinctions concern source transmission and differing dates, not a reconciled casualty list. [1]

That is not evidence that Mather was careless in every respect, nor that one date must automatically defeat the other. It is evidence that contemporaries possessed overlapping reports with differences important to modern chronology. A historian should not collapse them into a single tidy tale.

Faith, providence and authority

Mather interpreted the conflict through the religious language of providence, repentance and divine judgment. His perspective shaped the reasons he believed the history needed telling. Reading him fairly requires distinguishing that interpretation from his factual reports and identifying which official documents he reproduced rather than authored. [1]

The printer and the next war history

John Foster printed Mather’s 1676 volume. Foster also printed William Hubbard’s 1677 Narrative. The two histories have strikingly similar Swansea casualty sequences, and contemporaries discussed their relative reliability. A shared printer creates an important possible transmission route but does not prove one writer copied the other or that Foster himself altered the reports. [3]

The contemporary dispute

Letters associated with John Cotton Jr., Mather and the Plymouth leadership show that Hubbard’s printed book generated criticism and defense in 1677. The debate helps us understand how people then judged historical accuracy. It does not retroactively establish a trustworthy naming of Mather’s unnamed Swansea casualties. [3]

Other research from Mather’s diaries

Mather’s diaries supply a different view of his work: the arrival of reports in Boston before accounts were consolidated into print. A late-June 1675 entry, preserved in a Massachusetts Historical Society publication, reports seven English people killed and twenty houses burned at Swansea. That is what Mather recorded hearing, not independent verification that the numbers were correct. He noted the news in the context of fasting, prayer and an expedition then under way. It need not be made to agree with the nine deaths in his subsequent printed history. [4]

A later published set of diary extracts includes a July 1675 report of severe damage in Plymouth Colony, including Swansea, Dartmouth and Middleborough. Such reports reveal the pace and character of news reaching him; they are not eyewitness inventories. The diaries also record sermons, religious observances and longer-running concerns that illuminate his public ministry outside the single Swansea passage. [5]

Across the Atlantic: Mather’s London printing of 1676

Mather’s A Brief History was not confined to John Foster’s Boston press. Another edition appeared in London in the same year, printed for the bookseller Richard Chiswell at the Rose and Crown in St. Paul’s Churchyard. Its title page says it followed the original copy printed in New England. The bibliographic sequence is Boston 1676 first, London 1676 reprinting—not two separately collected sets of evidence about Swansea. The London version demonstrates how quickly a Boston account of the war could reach English readers. [8, 9]

The London printing is not identical to the Boston volume in every respect. A catalogue description from Indiana University expressly says that the separately printed “An Exhortation to the Inhabitants of New-England” (called a “Serious Exhortation” in some bibliographic descriptions), printed with the original Boston edition, is absent from the London edition, although the London title page still mentions it. That is a material difference in the contents of the printed book, not proof that the dates or victim counts in the war narrative were independently verified or authorially rewritten in England. A particular surviving London copy still needs collation before making claims about its exact textual readings, gatherings or completeness. [8, 10]

Bibliographical descriptions also identify a Massachusetts Bay colony seal on printed page 15 of the London volume that was cut anew after the Boston original. It is another example of overseas recutting: a London printing could imitate a New England graphic without using the same piece of printing wood. That seal is separate from the two “White Hills” and “Wine Hills” MAP blocks associated with Hubbard’s 1677 Boston and London editions; the histories, engravings and map traditions should not be mixed up. [11]

The two 1676 imprints can be compared through library catalogues and credited bibliographic descriptions without reproducing title-page photographs. The London imprint and the catalogue-noted omission of the exhortation are established at the edition-description level; neither a collation of the London war narrative nor image-reuse permission is implied. The Boston 1676 printing controls the Swansea passage cited here. A Relation of the Troubles Which Have Happened in New-England is another Mather work, not the London title of A Brief History. [1, 6, 8–11]

The available records describe the London 1676 edition as a reprint. They do not establish that copies of it were physically “returned” to Boston, recalled by Chiswell, or returned to Mather; no such movement should be asserted from the fact of a second printing alone.

More than one printed account of the war

Mather also wrote A Relation of the Troubles Which Have Happened in New-England (1676), a broader account of English and Indigenous relations and the causes of the conflict. He referred to official information and other written sources, including Plymouth materials, and gave his own providential interpretation of events. The separate Library scans labeled 1676 and 1677 require edition checking; they are not two independent witnesses merely because two files exist. [6]

Dorchester and the aftermath

A Renewal of Covenant, the Great Duty Incumbent on Decaying or Distressed Churches was preached for the Dorchester congregation and printed in 1677. The sermon documents Mather’s religious concerns and involvement in Dorchester in the period following the war. It is a theological work, not an eyewitness description of what happened at Swansea, and the sampled passages do not identify the Salisbury family. [7]

Mather’s published diary extracts also include a notice of the gathering of a church at Milton in April 1678. That entry is useful for the later ecclesiastical history of Milton even where it does not answer the book’s immediate casualty questions. A biography can preserve this broader context without introducing it prematurely into Chapter 05. [5]

The 1677 exchange in more detail

The surviving published correspondence gives Mather a more complicated role than simply criticizing William Hubbard from a distance. In his 21 April 1677 letter to John Cotton Jr., Mather said that he had supported Hubbard, supplied an approval and then withdrawn it. That is evidence of Mather’s stated conduct and reasons, not a finding that Hubbard’s account was inaccurate in every particular. The March–June 1677 correspondence also records objections, responses and contemporary comparisons of the two historians. Preserve the competing voices as such. [3]

What we can establish and what remains

Established: a 1676 printed account, its one-two-six enumeration, the conflicting Plymouth account in the postscript, the Foster printing, and the existence of a 1677 accuracy dispute. Not established: Mather’s personal witnessing of the Swansea incidents, which named men composed each casualty group, or direct textual borrowing by Hubbard. Those questions require source criticism rather than a conjectural identification. The remaining documented episodes in Mather’s work and life belong in this biography even when they do not bear directly on the Salisbury investigation.

Sources and further reading

[1] Increase Mather, A Brief History of the Warr with the Indians in New-England (Boston: John Foster, 1676), “To the Reader,” main narrative pp. 1–3, Mather’s own argument in separately paginated Postscript pp. 1–2 and Plymouth’s copied account in its p. 6; for providential interpretation also consult the separately paginated An Exhortation to the Inhabitants of New-England, pp. 3–6 (first Boston 1676 print facsimile checked 6 Nov 2026); for a later printed Plymouth text naming “Thomas layton,” see David Pulsifer, ed., Records of the Colony of New Plymouth, vol. 10, Acts of the Commissioners of the United Colonies, vol. 2 (Boston, 1859), 364.

[2] Swansea town-clerk annual vital-record return, dated 4 March 1675/76, manuscript fol. 64, FamilySearch group 007009308 image 200/369; printed in Nathaniel B. Shurtleff, ed., Records of the Colony of New Plymouth in New England, vol. 8 (Boston, 1857), 60–61. The manuscript return names burials; Mather’s prose does not name those nine.

[3] The Correspondence of John Cotton, Junior, vol. 79, Colonial Society of Massachusetts, “Recovery and Imperial Politics, 1676–1680,” letters of John Cotton Jr. to Increase Mather, 14 April 1677, and Increase Mather to Cotton, 21 April 1677, View source . Mather’s letter says he had encouraged Hubbard and withdrawn his approval; this is Mather’s firsthand account of his own stance, not independent proof of every alleged error in Hubbard’s work.

[4] Increase Mather’s diary, reports on 1675–76, printed in Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society (1899). Diary extracts preserve news Mather received, not independent verification of reported Swansea casualty totals.

[5] Belknap-related extracts from the diary of Increase Mather, 1674–1687, printed in Proceedings of the Massachusetts Historical Society (1900). This separate edited extraction is not a second firsthand observer.

[6] Increase Mather, A Relation of the Troubles Which Have Happened in New-England, seventeenth-century printings; issue and exact bibliographic identification must be confirmed before making page-level claims. Multiple editions are not independent event witnesses.

[7] Increase Mather, A Renewal of Covenant (Boston, 1677), based on his Dorchester sermon of 21 Mar 1677. The sermon date is not itself evidence that the printed edition circulated by 7 May.

[8] Indiana University Libraries, IUCAT catalogue, Increase Mather, A Brief History of the Warr with the Indians in New-England (London: printed for Richard Chiswell, 1676), View source . The catalogue notes that the separately printed “Serious exhortation” associated with the Boston original is absent in this London edition; this is a bibliographic description, not direct inspection of every London leaf.

[9] Christie’s catalogue description for the 1676 London edition, stating the London imprint and relationship to the Boston first printing: View source ; Boston first edition imprint at the Morgan Library & Museum: View source .

[10] University of Nebraska–Lincoln, scholarly electronic editions of Increase Mather, A Brief History (based on the Boston 1676 printing), View source , and An Earnest Exhortation to the Inhabitants of New-England, View source . These are distinct modern editions; do not substitute either for a page-level collation of a surviving London copy.

[11] Heritage Auctions, bibliographic description of London 1676 A Brief History, including the Massachusetts Bay woodcut seal recut from the Boston edition: View source . Claim concerns the graphic block, not the Hubbard 1677 map variants.

[12] Anonymous writer described as a Boston merchant, The Present State of New-England, with Respect to the Indian War (London: Dorman Newman, 1675), title page (license dated 13 Dec 1675); Indiana University Libraries catalogue, View source (disputed Saltonstall attribution). Increase Mather, A Brief History (Boston: John Foster, 1676), “To the Reader”; Paul Royster, ed., introduction to John Easton’s Relation, View source (possible identification of Mather’s unnamed Quaker). William Hubbard, The Present State of New-England: Being a Narrative of the Troubles with the Indians in New-England (London: Thomas Parkhurst, 1677), is a distinct 1677 edition of Hubbard, not the 1675 pamphlet.