Skip to content

James Cudworth

NOTABLE PEOPLE

James Cudworth

A magistrate who challenged religious persecution

James Cudworth was associated with Scituate in Plymouth Colony and served in the colony’s civil and military leadership. His earlier career was not a simple ascent through offices. In the late 1650s he objected to the colony’s treatment of Quakers, a position that cost him his magistracy and militia responsibilities. By June 1675 he had returned to public service and was commanding Plymouth Colony forces during the opening days of King Philip’s War. John G. Turner’s published historical account documents the interruption and return; the printed Plymouth court records provide additional evidence of Cudworth’s official position. This part of his life is worth preserving in a biography even though the Salisbury inquiry has a more immediate interest in his dispatches. [1, 2]

The evidence considered here is not a verified full family chronology, vital-record profile or complete sequence of civic offices. Later biographical sketches may suggest such details, but this account does not present them as established without underlying documentation.

A commander reporting from Swansea

Cudworth’s surviving wartime writing gives a close view of command at a moment when alarming news traveled more slowly than events. It is not a diary of everything he witnessed. Some statements describe his own actions; others are estimates, intercepted news, messengers’ accounts and revised assessments. His letters make the distinction visible, sometimes with a few words. The documentary sequence is especially valuable because the sources can be read in chronological order without inventing a continuous eyewitness narrative. [3–5]

June 24, 1675: Two different messages on one sheet

A manuscript page in the Massachusetts Archives Collection, vol. 67, p. 203, contains two separately signed pieces. The upper report belongs to William Bradford, Constant Southworth and James Browne. It describes Swansea residents withdrawing into defended locations, reports roughly twelve or thirteen houses entered or plundered on June 23 and records later news that an English passerby had been fired upon but survived. The lower message bears Cudworth’s signature. The two communications must not be read as one letter from Cudworth merely because they appear together on the page. [3]

Cudworth’s own message says he arrived at Swansea about midday on June 24 with eighty men. He requested ammunition and approximately two hundred reinforcements. The opposing Indigenous force was “said to be 6 or 7 hundred”—a report of what he was told, not an enemy muster personally counted by him. His arrival, the requested reinforcement and the rumored opposing strength are three different kinds of numbers. The document identifies his location broadly as Swansea, not at a particular house, guard post or battlefield. [3]

The recipient is identified in the archival description as the Massachusetts governor; Cudworth’s manuscript salutation itself is only “Sr.” His signed lower message does not mention the six later reported killed at Mattapoisett, and that omission alone does not prove the deaths had not yet happened. The exact writing and news-arrival times cannot be recovered merely from the sheet’s date. [3]

June 25: The message we have not found

On June 25 Nathaniel Thomas wrote from Swansea to Governor Josiah Winslow that he expected the governor to have received a “particular account” from “our General” concerning a loss of six men at Mattapoisett the previous day. The nineteenth-century printed edition supplies Cudworth’s name in brackets; the surviving quoted words from Thomas do not. The attribution is reasonable in view of the command structure, but readers should be able to distinguish the original phrase from editorial identification. [4]

Cudworth’s longer letter dated June 27 opens by referring to an earlier communication to Winslow sent by post around the morning of June 25, with Boston and John Jacob mentioned. These references may point to the same missing report, but their identity has not been proved. There may have been more than one communication. Neither surviving reference tells us whether the missing document named any of the six dead, recorded the exact site or described something quite routine. Searches through relevant correspondence and archival leads have not produced its text. [4, 5]

June 27: Reports from the road and from the guards

Cudworth’s 27 June letter survives in the Josiah Winslow Papers at the Boston Athenæum (Mss. .L461). The three-page manuscript text ends with his signature, and the exterior bears an address and docket. Historian John G. Turner brought the letter into a wider historical discussion. Readings quoted or paraphrased here follow a collation of manuscript photographs against a diplomatic transcription, not a string of independent contemporary accounts. [1, 5, 6]

Cudworth writes that intelligence reached him concerning two Englishmen killed in the road and a horse shot dead. The two men had been sent at night to summon “Dr Fuller” for the wounded at the Rev. John Myles’s guard. Captain Savage, Captain Oliver and Mr. Brattle later saw the bodies during a separate journey intended to speak with Philip, a mission they abandoned. Those three observers were not the two men who went for the surgeon. Cudworth reports the bodies stripped and mutilated, but does not name the victims or give the exact road, departure point or place from which the doctor was to be summoned. The identification of the doctor as Captain Matthew Fuller is plausible in related research, not supplied in full by the letter. [5, 7]

Cudworth also recorded intelligence about Layton being “shot downe ded at his dore.” Goodman Harvey and James Lenon are named as sources of this news. That passage supplies a reported death and some claimed informants, not an eyewitness statement that Cudworth stood at Layton’s doorway. [5]

A network of guards, messengers and decisions

The June 27 letter lists guards at Mattapoisett, Mr. Sharpe’s, Mr. Myles’s, and Captain Willett’s house; it places the main guard at Mr. Browne’s. Cudworth said ten or twelve horsemen were needed to carry news between posts and that he could not leave the main guard. Command, in this record, involved decisions made without constant personal observation of the positions under his care. [5]

On Friday, June 25, he sent thirty men to the Mattapoisett guard to join sixteen from Bridgewater, protect residents and move people and possessions away. By around noon on Sunday, June 27, he still had no report from the thirty men. We have evidence of an order and of an information gap, but not proof from this letter that the entire rescue movement was carried out as planned. [5]

The letter also records exchanges with Rhode Island Governor Coddington, proposed coordination involving boats and waterways, intelligence concerning Narragansett and Pocasset movements, reports from Taunton and Rehoboth, and expected supplies or reinforcements. Some of these were rumors or tactical judgments about Indigenous leaders and alliances; the narrative must not reproduce colonial suspicions as verified descriptions of Indigenous intentions. The broader correspondence shows how Cudworth’s military work extended beyond the few incidents relevant to the Salisbury investigation. [5]

Correcting his own report

The treatment of casualties at Mr. Myles’s guard is a revealing example of Cudworth’s method. Early in the June 27 letter he introduces an account with “it seemes,” describing one sentinel killed and two additional men thought mortally wounded. Later, after men return from the post, he labels the newer report “the Right Relation.” [5]

In the corrected passage, Gershom Cobb is reported killed while on sentinel duty. John Morton is mortally wounded, but Cudworth adds that there is some hope for his life. Alexander Canady was shot in the shoulder. An unnamed Black man enslaved by Myles was reported to have “no hope of life.” These are DIFFERENT reported conditions; Cudworth documents one death in this section, not proof that the three wounded men had already died. Turner’s later research draws attention to Hubbard’s statement that the enslaved man died subsequently, while his name remains unrecovered. The later report must not be read backward into what Cudworth knew in June 1675. [1, 5]

The corrected entry shows a commander updating the governor when information changed. It also shows the stark inequality of surviving identification: three of the four men could be named, but the enslaved man’s injury was communicated without a personal name. No invented name, family relationship or precise death date belongs in the biography. [1, 5]

Mattapoisett: An important loss without a roster

Cudworth speaks of “the men killed at Mattapoyset,” distinct from the two killed in the road and the injuries at Myles’s guard. Nathaniel Thomas reports six lost there on June 24. Cudworth’s surviving passage does not itself count or name those men. The two descriptions cannot automatically be treated as independent eyewitness confirmation of the same information, nor does either give a named death roster. [4, 5]

Nicholas Tanner, Swansea’s clerk, later sent Plymouth Colony a court-ordered annual return listing nine men as buried under June 24, including William and John Salisbury. The return does not allocate any of the nine to the six reported lost at Mattapoisett and does not state the place where either Salisbury died. It is a separate administrative record of burials, not a source identifying Cudworth’s unnamed men. [8]

The surviving manuscripts and their editions

The 24 June material is a single Massachusetts Archives sheet carrying separately signed communications. The 27 June report is a different, three-body-page letter with an exterior address held at the Boston Athenæum. Modern photographs showing details of that manuscript are not separate letters or corroborating contemporary witnesses. [3, 6]

Nathaniel Thomas’s June 25 words are currently cited from an 1854 printed transcription, not from a manuscript inspected independently for this project. The printed edition and the later machine-generated transcription are derivative versions, not independent manuscript witnesses. The absent Cudworth correspondence cannot be reconstructed from Thomas or Hubbard; it remains an absence in the documentary chain. [4, 9]

Researchers may compare Cudworth’s letter to Hubbard’s subsequent printed surgeon and six-death passages, but similarity does not demonstrate that Hubbard possessed this particular letter. That textual comparison is treated in a separate book chapter; this biography preserves Cudworth’s broader conduct and contemporary information environment. [7]

Reading these documents online

The three dated source layers—24 June dispatches, Thomas’s 25 June letter as printed in 1854, and Cudworth’s surviving 27 June manuscript—should be read in sequence without inventing a missing dispatch. They represent military decisions, reports from others, later corrections and retrospective printing. The original spelling and unresolved letterforms matter whenever exact quotation is required; none of these texts supplies a verified named roster of the six Mattapoisett casualties. [3–9]

This account cites the surviving records without reproducing manuscript images. [6, 9]

Sources and further reading

[1] John G. Turner, “Mr. Miles His Negro No Hope of Life,” Yale University Press blog, 13 April 2020, View source . Consult for Cudworth’s Scituate background, objection to persecution of Quakers, later wartime service and recovery of Hubbard’s report about the unnamed man.

[2] Plymouth Colony Court Orders, 1 June 1675, in Nathaniel B. Shurtleff, ed., Records of the Colony of New Plymouth in New England, vol. 5 (Boston, 1856), 163. Nineteenth-century printed transcription of a seventeenth-century order.

[3] William Bradford, Constant Southworth, and James Browne, report; James Cudworth, separately signed communication, Swansea, 24 June 1675, Massachusetts Archives Collection, vol. 67, p. 203; FamilySearch image group 007702977, image 1686 of 1698. The two signatory components on the sheet should not be collapsed into one eyewitness statement.

[4] Nathaniel Thomas to Josiah Winslow, 25 June 1675, printed in Marcia Abiah Thomas, Memorials of Marshfield (Boston, 1854), 55. The original manuscript has not been independently examined here. Thomas refers to a “particular account” from “our General”; the edition supplies [Cudworth] in brackets, an editorial identification rather than a name Thomas wrote. The account has not been recovered, and its identity with the earlier dispatch mentioned in Cudworth’s 27 June letter remains unproved.

[5] James Cudworth to Josiah Winslow, 27 June 1675, Josiah Winslow Papers, Mss. .L461, Boston Athenæum, three manuscript body pages and exterior address. This profile’s attributed reports follow the manuscript-source collation; uncertain handwriting should not be presented as a certain literal quotation.

[6] James Cudworth to Josiah Winslow, 27 June 1675, Josiah Winslow Papers, Mss. .L461, Boston Athenæum; three surviving manuscript body pages, one exterior address/docket. The repository’s catalogue and manuscript description identify the surviving document; modern photographs are not additional contemporary witnesses.

[7] James Cudworth to Josiah Winslow, 27 June 1675, Josiah Winslow Papers, Mss. .L461, Boston Athenæum; Swansea Baptist Church records, Mss C 2499, American Ancestors / New England Historic Genealogical Society, and Robert Charles Anderson’s edited transcription, New England Historical and Genealogical Register 139 (1985): 21–49. Distinct manuscripts and editions, not interchangeable source witnesses.

[8] Nicholas Tanner’s Swansea annual return, dated 4 March 1675/76, printed in Nathaniel B. Shurtleff, ed., Records of the Colony of New Plymouth in New England, vol. 8 (Boston, 1857), 60–61; compare the distinct handwritten colony return, manuscript fol. 64, FamilySearch group 007009308, image 200 of 369. Shurtleff’s printed edition is a transcription of the return, not a second original witness.

[9] James Cudworth, 27 June 1675 letter, Josiah Winslow Papers, Mss. .L461, Boston Athenæum. The surviving 27 June manuscript does not establish the contents of the earlier, unrecovered 25 June communication.