Skip to content

Menenie

PROBATE BIOGRAPHIES

Menenie

A Life Partly Visible Through a Suffolk Probate Record, 1675

A name preserved in a probate register

In 1675, a Suffolk County, Massachusetts Bay probate clerk recorded the estate of a deceased person called “Menenie Negro.” This is the name and period description in the record; it is not a modern surname, and it does not by itself establish whether Menenie was enslaved or free. Other details of Menenie’s life remain difficult to recover: birthplace, parentage, age, residence, occupation, and date or circumstances of death are not established by the material presently examined.

The inventory nevertheless preserves evidence that rarely enters the historical accounts of King Philip’s War: a list of someone’s belongings, their recorded value, and the name of a woman who appeared in the ensuing estate proceedings. These should be considered as Menenie’s own documentary history, not merely as possible clues to somebody else’s identity.

The estate and its belongings

The copied probate register contains an inventory of Menenie’s goods, provisionally transcribed in the project’s source file as clothing, a bedstead and bedding, iron pots, a brass skillet, a warming pan, pewter dishes, glassware, hearth ironwork, furniture, and other household goods. The recorded total is £9 14s 6d.

The inventory bears a date provisionally read as 4 July 1675. Its appraisers signed “19:6:75,” corresponding to 19 August 1675 under the contemporary numbered-month convention. These dates and their respective legal meanings still require a final comparison with the manuscript. Neither is a confirmed date of death.

An inventory tells us what appraisers listed and valued for probate. It does not necessarily list everything a person used, reveal who purchased an item, or establish the final net estate after obligations and distributions. The fact that Menenie’s goods were recorded does not prove an inference about legal status that the probate language itself does not supply.

Dorcas: another name in the proceeding

A subsequent Suffolk probate entry dated “7:25:1675” (25 September 1675) involves a woman named Dorcas. The working reading of her surname is “Manning,” but that name and the exact wording of the administration entry still require paleographic verification. The note places her appearance before Governor John Leverett and Samuel Symonds. It has not yet established what legal act she was performing.

Who was Dorcas to Menenie? A wife or widow, mother, sister, another relative, a household associate, a creditor, or a person acting in another legal capacity are all possibilities to be tested against the record. At present, none is proved. In particular, the document does not presently justify calling them a married couple or assigning Dorcas a race, legal status, residence, or family relationship. The exact words surrounding her name may be among the most informative parts of this small surviving paper trail.

Where Menenie lived—and why Suffolk handled the estate

This document belongs to the Suffolk County probate records of Massachusetts Bay, not Plymouth Colony. The present research does not establish where Menenie ordinarily lived, where Menenie died, or why the estate came within that court’s proceedings. A probate jurisdiction is not, without further evidence, a birthplace, residence, or place of death.

The records worth checking next are those that might clarify the court’s connection to Menenie, the terms of Dorcas’s participation, and the identities of any named appraisers or other parties. This short biography leaves those questions open rather than supplying a plausible-sounding household history.

An unproved connection to John Myles’s unnamed servant

Another contemporary source, James Cudworth’s letter to Governor Josiah Winslow dated 27 June 1675, reports the grave wounding of an unnamed Black man enslaved by the Swansea Baptist minister John Myles. Cudworth did not give his name. William Hubbard later wrote that this injured man died. While independently examining Suffolk County probate records, I discovered Menenie’s inventory and subsequently considered whether it could provide a name missing from the war accounts. No connection has been proved.

There is no established documentary connection between Menenie and Myles. The Suffolk estate does not name Myles, identify Menenie as enslaved, or place Menenie at Swansea. The proximity of the dates is a research lead, not proof of identity. The fuller investigation and the Suffolk–Plymouth jurisdiction question are explored in a separate Mysteries investigation, “The Servant Without a Name.” Neither article should imply that the mystery has been solved.

Read the record

Suffolk County Probate Court, Massachusetts Bay Colony, copied probate register, manuscript pages 266–267; inventory for “Menenie Negro” and related proceedings; FamilySearch, “Suffolk, Massachusetts, United States records,” image group 007703071, image 149 of 922:

View source

The provider link points to the manuscript opening, which also includes a separate Scottish merchant’s inventory. John Fans’s estate is a different record, and shared page placement is not evidence of a connection. FamilySearch access conditions may vary. No manuscript image is reproduced here.

Sources and further reading

[1] Suffolk County Probate Court, copied probate register, manuscript pp. 266–267, Menenie inventory and Dorcas proceeding, 1675; FamilySearch image group 007703071, image 149/922. Interpretations of the names, dates, inventory entries, total, and legal roles remain provisional pending full comparison with the original handwriting.

[2] James Cudworth to Josiah Winslow, 27 June 1675, Josiah Winslow Papers, Boston Athenæum, Mss. .L461. The letter’s unnamed person should not be equated with Menenie without further evidence.

[3] James Cudworth to Josiah Winslow, 27 June 1675, original manuscript in the Josiah Winslow Papers, Boston Athenæum, Mss. .L461; and William Hubbard, A Narrative of the Troubles with the Indians in New-England (Boston, 1677). These are separate witnesses concerning the unnamed man, not evidence establishing Menenie’s identity.

[4] William Hubbard, A Narrative of the Troubles with the Indians in New-England (Boston, 1677), later report that the unnamed wounded man died.

Related research

The Servant Without a Name — A Suffolk Probate Puzzle. This separate article investigates the unproved possibility of a connection between Menenie and John Myles’s unnamed servant and explores the unresolved identity of Dorcas.